South of Broad By Pat Conroy

September 2, 2009


Pat Conroy’s “South of Broad” audiobook, narrated by Mark Deacons, reels the listener in with its richly captivating voice, for the most part, yet it could possibly benefit immeasurably from intermittent music, provided that it doesn’t interfere with the oration. Many fiction audiobooks in this genre suffer a similar fate: it may be useful for narrators to borrow form old-time radio standards of the fifties to provide inspiration and examples: perhaps an introduction with music that somehow sews together this tightly knit community of Charleston, South Carolina, could add greatly to the dramatic effect of the piece. The orator from “South of Broad” in moments seems slightly emotionally removed from the dialogue, thereby producing a mechanical performance—one that leaves the listener unaffected. The accent also is pronounced and heightened successfully at times, while at other times the accent appears to fall by the way side. Before an audiobook release of a professional caliber, there needs to be careful attention on the accent, so that it can replete the fictive work instead of draw from it; Deacon’s narration, although effective at times, pulls the listener out of the experience because of the flimsy accent.

The highly masculine, powerful voice that crackles with confidence may successfully project the novelist’s intention, but when there are abundant choices within the current audiobook fiction cannon, sound is the only medium in which to produce results, so it needs to grab the listener’s ears and not let go. This is not to say that Deacon’s relatively perfunctory narration may be above his rivals; in fact, many competitors in this genre tend to sound at times like bankers instead of storytellers. The narrator in “The Time Traveler’s Wife” seems to have the whole thing down however: there appears to be energy in the right place—appropriate, believable enthusiasm that suffers far less monotony than so many other audio narratives. In addition, the narration in the “Traveler’s Wife” effectively ranges from energetic, mysterious voicing that aptly drops into a whisper when the right moment approaches. Like any art form however, the process of effective audio narration requires talent, patience and the ability to captivate an audience. This does not require pandering to an audience that is only capable of being interested at the sound of sex and violence, yet it requires some analysis, and perhaps once again, it may require borrowing from the genius of fifties radio narration.

Random Posts

The Angel’s Game By Carlos Ruiz Zafon
In Fed We Trust-A Review by David Wessel
The Strain by Guillermo Del Toro and Chuck Hogan
Matters of the Heart By Danielle Steel
Finger Lickin’ Fifteen By Janet Evanovich
Review of She Comes First
Audio Book review – Ted Kennedy: The Dream That Never Died by Edward Klein
The Neighbor by Lisa Gardner
Real Life Fairy Tales? The Forgotten Garden By Kate Morton
In Bed with Susie Bright
The Compleat Gentleman: The Modern Man’s Guide to Chivalry By Brad Miner
Como Hacer el Amor toda la Noche by Barbara Keesling, Ph.D.
The Fixer Upper By Mary Kay Andrews
The Ultimate Depression Survival Guide: Protect Your Savings, Boost Your Income, and Grow Wealthy by Martin D. Weiss
Outliers Book Review

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: